top of page

PASTOR
Rev. Josh Fitterling

IMG_1517_edited.jpg

Pastor Josh was born in rural Pennsylvania, where he was raised on his family’s farm. Though he knew at an early age that farming was not his calling in life, he learned a lot along the way, and he remains grateful for the opportunities found there! Hard work and determination that are cornerstones of farm life remain important parts of his identity.

​

While his family has always had a connection to church, Pastor Josh’s own love and appreciation of church began in his early teens when he and his brother became active members of Salem Belleman’s Church (an ELCA and UCC shared ministry) in Mohrsville, PA. It was in this faith community where his own faith deepened and his call to ministry began to emerge. During that time, he found great fulfillment going on service trips around the United States to help rebuild after natural disasters. Since then, the importance of being of service to others and putting faith into action has remained a cornerstone of his faith.

​

Following High School, Pastor Josh went on to graduate from Lebanon Valley College (’12) in Annville, PA where he studied mathematics and from Lancaster Theological Seminary (’15) in Lancaster, PA where he received his Master of Divinity degree. He was ordained in the United Church of Christ on May 24, 2015. Since then, he has served a variety of churches in different capacities in Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, and Maine. He has experience in rural, suburban, and urban churches as well as in churches of varying sizes. Much of his work has involved community engagement and finding ways of expanding the reach of a church out into their wider community. No matter the setting, Pastor Josh has always found great joy in creating meaningful worship experiences, building community connections, and finding ways of meeting people where they are!

​

In the Spring of 2024, Pastor Josh took a reprieve from parish work to spend the summer working at Pilgrim Lodge (the Maine Conference camp of the UCC) where he served as their Summer Program Coordinator. Here he supported the camp experiences created for youth, families, and adults. Afterwards, he moved south just outside Knoxville, TN where he has served as a Chaplain Resident at UT Medical Center for the past year. While grateful for these opportunities, he is excited to return to church ministry!

​

Pastor Josh lives near Knoxville with his partner of two years, Daniel, as well as their dog (Hero), cat (Nutmeg), and bird (Marlin). Daniel has spent most of his life in Tennessee, is a graduate of Maryville College (’17), and works for Clayton Homes. Together, they enjoy going on adventures, bowling, watching a good show, and spending time with friends.

​

In his spare time, Pastor Josh also enjoys reading (often fiction for fun!), listening to podcasts, and teaching himself how to play piano! When he is able, he loves to visit his parents and brother back home on the family farm.

​

Pastor Josh serves Bethany “bilocationally” (a term he crafted when beginning to explore this opportunity). He spends a couple days each week in Claremont and the other half outside Knoxville with his partner, while still being accessible by phone and email as needed. He is excited to nurture the ministry of Bethany UCC as a progressive and welcoming light in Claremont and beyond! 

ORGANIST
Jane Campbell


 

Screenshot 2026-05-13 105728.png
Screenshot 2026-05-13 110009.png

PASTOR EMERITUS

Rev. Nevin Feather

 

bottom of page